Both are gorgeous ladies, but Kareena is a better actress in roles with varying shades of character. I admire Ash tremendously, but I doubt she could have emoted well to display negative traits in a character. Her face and eyes are suited for characterizing innocence and simplicity.

Kareena was the first choice, she is a amazing actress. She is better choice. 

Def Kareena who is a much more versatile actress.  She has the oomph factor which Aish lacks esp in roles of this caliber.  Take Dhoom 2 for example – aside from the dance scenes casting Aish wasn’t the best choice!

Kareena

of course ……KAREENA………….

of course ……KAREENA………….

I’d say  Ash b’cos  she has given her best work to directors who know how to get the best out of her,like Sanjay Leela Bhansali, Mani Ratnam  & Rituparno  Ghosh. Madhur would have definately given her a very good award winning role. Kareena is good too,but Ash would have been better for the box office. And I say this very neutrally as I’m am not a particular fan of either.

KAREENA 

KAREENA 

ash is beautiful but  she luks like an alien in thz pic.

Aishwarya is a striking beauty with acting skills to match, the dream beauty would of been better. Madhur knows who the more popular of the 2 is, that is why he used Aishwarya’s name to promote the movie at Cannes.

aishwarya

kareena looks like a man, aishwarya is hot

Aish

Ash rai pic is sooo fake .come on she doesn’t like that at all. Who agree

Ash rai pic is Sooo fake , too much light and camera Etc .come on she doesn’t look like that at all .who agree? At least kareena is real

Aishwarya <3 would of given a tremendous performance as Herione, in
order to be real the audience will have to empathize with you, the audience empathized with her in roles like Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam, Devdas & Guzaarish. Kareena comes across more obnoxious. I prefer Aishwarya 100%<3<3

kareena is the better choice…her picture is more natural while Ash looks like she’s really putting it on.

I disagree …kareena was fantastic in Jab we Met and everyone empathized with her character.  Bodyguard was such a subtle performance and so natural. Anyway Ash is much more older than kareena as well

that is such a mean comment…from where does she look like a man???

sooooooooooo beautifull kareena

Aishwarya Bachchan

age has nothing to do with the role in this movie . and aishwarya is more beautiful than kareena and has more fan supportive from men and women.

kareena kapoor , looks more sexier and more charming!!!!aish is not bad too but she just get a baby and she is gonna need more time to get her self back, and more time with her baby, come on at least 1 yrs before she start acting..so my opinion
is kareena, but im sure katrina will do better than 2 of them, because katrina has stylish look…

dude are serious…???…katrina can’t act …or speak hindi properly…!!! ..you may like her that is fine…but we are talking about a woman oriented flick..where the actress is the main focus…katrina not being able to act will be more visible…!!! besides that she was never in the running…

right choice is obviously aishwarya…!!! she can act circles around kareena all the while looking glamorous and beautiful…kareena is not anywhere in aishwarya’s league..!!!

You mean Anty or Babe?

wrong yashraj is very good at casting…aishwarya has oomph !!!…had they cast kareena it would of flopped..remember tashan where kareena tried to be sexy??..failure..!!!

wrong yashraj is very good at casting…aishwarya has oomph !!!…had they cast kareena it would of flopped..remember tashan where kareena tried to be sexy??..failure..!!!

aishwarya is right choice

i like Aishwarya 

ash for sure

I like Kareena but no one can compete with QUEEN Ash!  Ash is the BEST, she can do any character and anyone that says she can’t play negative characters should watch Khakee and Dhoom 2!, She rocked in both movies! Ash has, beauty,talent and she dances really good.

Ash would of rocked in Herione and gave Madhur Bhandarker a hit but oh well it is his loss!

Whose the anty? lol? checking out the mirror again?

lyk duhh its kareena, and not that plastic , fake woman aishwarya rai and so called bachchan

NONE OF THE BITCHES

Aishwarya = stunning actress  Kareena = she male
i go with Aishwarya

ASH!!!!

aishwarya rai better than kareena kapoor….ash is the best glamour…

KAREENA!!!!!

You are right kanchan. Katrina is casted only to attract the public that’s all. Queen… please watch katrina’s movies again and judge it yourself. Her movies are hits ONLY and ONLY because of her co-stars. By the way she is very beautiful but she sucks as in acting. As kanchan said she can not be compared with Ash and Bebo since they proved themselves in terms of acting and looks.

kareena is much suitable than ash …and katrina is much better than kareena….if u want an acting in film named herione….priyanka chopra is a much better performer in acting in them all mentioned celebrities…
its my opinion…
shahidjmeel from khyber pakhtoon khwa,Pakistan

Although I really like Kareena, no one can compare with Ash’s beauty- she is the definition of a glamourous heroine. So definitely Ash for this project!

Beautiful Aishwarya Rai of course

of course aishwariya rai bachan

aishwarya is better choice she da only choice

People have had enough of fake bitch ashwariya..shes better off looking after beti bitch bachan. so kareen is the young bomb..ash is old school and too fake

Kareena

Of course kareena, ashwariya is a fake bitch and too old

fuck you zeenath peanut…ashs arsewipe…kareena should be the one

ash looks like a broken pussy, push and push and push and looking old the fucking cunt..hope she dies, hope bachans die…fuken boring batch

very true. ashwariya character was fake, accent so damn fake when she tried to false love and speak in english, hahaha wants to make me laugh, pathetic

The word Heroine speaks 4 itself, Aishwarya the Queen of Bollywood maybe when she retires that when Kareena can take da lead…… bt 4 now Only AISH Bebs……………………………………………….And b4 i 4got she will b back after 8months

kareena may be younger but she looks like old bat aishwarya is way better . kareena looks like a hooker

kareena may be younger but she looks like old bat aishwarya is way better . kareena looks like a hooker

fuck you nasty bitch don’t tell anyone who to choose kareena is stupid hooker trash

aishwarya

You call Aish Old,she mayb older than Kareena bt prettier than her (kareena) and Aish looks younger

aishwarya…is a better actress n a more popular actress…kareena is brainless bobble head..

fake id rizali somy sara person…vagabond

fake id somy sara …person

Aishwarya Rai ;;;is  battar;””’;;;;;Actress  ;;’,'; And sexy                                                                     
         I love you  Ash

aishwarya is my choice,she is gouges,talented,stunning actress compare to kareena
but i like kareena too.

aishawriya fantastic actrees

ashh for sure ,kareena  and heroine oesnt work at all, i think katrinaa is best for herpine. between ash and kareena, ashhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh.

going by this particular picture it has to be Kareena. she looks so effortless and stylish and a HEROINE. but ash looks trying hard and failing miserably. lets wait for the film. hope that doesnt change my perspective. 

according to vote,the winner is aish.

oh ash is so fake.kareena is more suitable for the film.

KAREENA! KAREENA! KAREENA!

this pic is nt so taken perfectly……..kareena is trying 2 b aish cuz aish is simple and beautiful n wen she dresses up,shes jst awesome..kareena is fake….

kareena no doubt,i  hate aish i dont why i dont find any thing gud about her,

ash is lovely and beautiful but not a good actress but kareena is a good actress both have their own qualities and thats why they both are successful so ppl honour them both in positive ways i liked ash in her old days but not now but kareena has yet to prove herself she has a long way to go her sister for example in fiza was brilliant and both have not achieved that level yet.

Who said Kareena is good actress, she looks like a man. Kareena is rubbish. Ash all the way 

Hate is a very strong word I think you are jealous of Ash.You have to be a gay to love kareena who looks like a man.

Hate is a very strong word I think you are jealous of Ash.You have to be a gay to love kareena who looks like a man.

Ash Ash Ash Ashshe is sour grapes for Madhur Bhandarkar.  

Yor are so thick you can not see who is fake it is Kareena can not even act, she is cashing her family name. Heroine is going to be a flop film.

You should be ashamed of yourself using this b…. word. Kareena is a man with looooooong ugly face.
Ash looks younger and more beautiful than her. She is a classy beauty.

You are unfit to come on the blog . You should be in mental hospital.

Jealous

What do you know granny

go to optician

Well, I Suppose Ashwariya Has The Attitude To Play This Role Finely In This Film

Kareena. Ash  looks pretty but I personally dont think so can execute this role the way kareena could ever. I personally  think Kareena is prettier and acts very well. So I am glad she took this role. I am excited to see the movie

She doesnt look like a man at all. I dont know if you have seen them with out makeup but I have met them both with out anything done to them and I have to say kareena looks just like she does on screen. naturally beautiful. Ash did not even look as pretty. She look okay but not at all what she looks like on screen. She has pretty features which capture well on screen but that does not translate over in person at all.

Aishwarya she is much more beautiful look at and she emotes well

the morons that said kareena is more beautiful than aishwarya do you live under a rock aishwarya is called the most beautiful lady in the world. aishwarya is more loved and hotter looking than kareena. i would like to  see aishwarya any day of the week

aishwarya looks beautiful in person i met her., she way hotter than kareena. aamir ,srk and salman have talked about aishwarya’s devastating beauty. they loved her without makeup aamir wanted her to do the role in rising because he said aishwarya is one of the few ladies that look beautiful without makeup. aishwarya and beautiful is synonymous. kareena will be not considered a universal beauty , when aishwarya retire it will be katriina taking over the beauty tag though aishwarya is more hotter than either of them.

aishwarya looks beautiful in person i met her., she way hotter than kareena. aamir ,srk and salman have talked about aishwarya’s devastating beauty. they loved her without makeup aamir wanted her to do the role in rising because he said aishwarya is one of the few ladies that look beautiful without makeup. aishwarya and beautiful is synonymous. kareena will be not considered a universal beauty , when aishwarya retire it will be katriina taking over the beauty tag though aishwarya is more hotter than either of them.

Aish love her

Aish love her

Aishwarya Bachchan is a excellent actress and has stunning looks and glamor to carry the role.

kareena is an exceptional actor but i had my heart set on aishwariya to do this role..her photoshoot which was leaked just made her ideal for the role..she was mesmerising throughout/.its a shame that she couldnt do the film..but i hope kareena lives up to it.. 

Aishwarya Rai aaaaaaaalllllllllllllll the wayyyyyyyyyyyyyy!

Ok Granny and babe. I was being too kind to Ash. Thanks for pointing this out.

shut up country bumpkin kareena wishes she was a babe she doesn’t look pretty ,she looks like paris hilton

who cares you must not have any style

aishwarya rai b

excusme kareenais looks better thn ash aunti

excusme kareenais looks better thn ash aunti

my bebo karena love youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
ash is looking horrible

aishwarya is beautiful and can do this movie effortlessly

95% voting goes…………………….to AISH and 5% to KAREENA
 And now u see why Heroine will be a flop

Its the director who makes the difference…especially Bhandarkar has his own way of presenting an actor.So any one can fit the role.

Both actresses are amazing, there is nothing left to compare here, let Bebo do her job, why compare her with others.
If comparison has to be done, then let ” Heroine 2  ” come out after this , and let Madhur sign Aish then .

totaly!

That’s the biggest problem with lots of people and that really enerved me! Most people love Aish because of her beauty and whenever there is a poll you only hear the same thing that she is the most beautiful ,true she is a beauty  and a great dancer but she is not the most talented! Why not judge an actress from her talent and not always her beauty? Kareena is maybe not the most beautiful but that lady has lots of talent and she is versatile and convincing in her roles.Aish has played in some Hollywood films and really when one remove all the dancing and singing that exist in Bollywood and concentrate only on acting ,compare to Hollywood stars Aish is really not  that good an actress,sorry nothing against her but that’s the truth. Do you really think that she would have  such a big career has she not been such a beauty? Don’t think so .

katrina has improve a lot now days, and she is on demand, also she young beautiful sexy hot, that’s heroine, we dont want heroine to be like aish, my opinion, aish is a little bit tired and old for this role, and kareena maybe if they choose her , but katreena has everything to this role, true she doesnt catch up good the hindi, but she try very hard, and she is one of our future in the industry..why not her

yeah she is really beautiful sexy , someone who attract the audience, now days, people dont care about acting too much , we have  alot people acting zero in bollywood , and the audience love to watch them,as long as u sexy beautiful and and u have a strong role and a strong co star, that’s matter..and she is one of the beauty in bollywood..im not defending her, but im just saying my opinion, kareena has been in the industry, and she start get succes recently from 3 idiots,  and bodyguard give her the big succes plus raone.. but before that she was not qualified as a good actress.and aish was behind too, her last movie guzzarish, has lift her a little bit up, and she got the tag of miss world, that’s why she is still smelling alive , but nothing new on her…people are just intresting on aishwarya only if a story with salman khan get involve,because people love to know what’s going on betwen the two stars, but nobody is intresting, to abishek

I am a old tranny queen my face  look like an old woman’s ass when she try to shit. but my ass is a big hole. any thing and everything will get inside my hole. i have no hole in the front , only a penis.people shit on my face when they see how ugly i look. they think i am a freaky wild animal children run screaming if they see my ugly face, that’s why i hate Aiswarya Rai. everyone loves her. so i fake so many names an comment.i am an ugly bitch.

I am a old tranny queen my face  look like an old woman’s ass when she try to shit. but my ass is a big hole. any thing and everything will get inside my hole. i have no hole in the front , only a penis.people shit on my face when they see how ugly i look. they think i am a freaky wild animal children run screaming if they see my ugly face, that’s why i hate Aiswarya Rai. everyone loves her. so i fake so many names an comment.i am an ugly bitch.

I am a old tranny queen my face  look like an old woman’s ass when she try to shit. but my ass is a big hole. any thing and everything will get inside my hole. i have no hole in the front , only a penis.people shit on my face when they see how ugly i look. they think i am a freaky wild animal children run screaming if they see my ugly face, that’s why i hate Aiswarya Rai. everyone loves her. so i fake so many names an comment.i am an ugly bitch.

I am a old tranny queen my face  look like an old woman’s ass when she try to shit. but my ass is a big hole. any thing and everything will get inside my hole. i have no hole in the front , only a penis.people shit on my face when they see how ugly i look. they think i am a freaky wild animal children run screaming if they see my ugly face, that’s why i hate Aiswarya Rai. everyone loves her. so i fake so many names an comment.i am an ugly bitch.

I am a old tranny queen my face  look like an old woman’s ass when she try to shit. but my ass is a big hole. any thing and everything will get inside my hole. i have no hole in the front , only a penis.people shit on my face when they see how ugly i look. they think i am a freaky wild animal children run screaming if they see my ugly face, that’s why i hate Aiswarya Rai. everyone loves her. so i fake so many names an comment.i am an ugly bitch.

I am a old tranny queen my face  look like an old woman’s ass when she try to shit. but my ass is a big hole. any thing and everything will get inside my hole. i have no hole in the front , only a penis.people shit on my face when they see how ugly i look. they think i am a freaky wild animal children run screaming if they see my ugly face, that’s why i hate Aiswarya Rai. everyone loves her. so i fake so many names an comment.i am an ugly bitch.

I am a old tranny queen my face  look like an old woman’s ass when she try to shit. but my ass is a big hole. any thing and everything will get inside my hole. i have no hole in the front , only a penis.people shit on my face when they see how ugly i look. they think i am a freaky wild animal children run screaming if they see my ugly face, that’s why i hate Aiswarya Rai. everyone loves her. so i fake so many names an comment.i am an ugly bitch.

I am a old tranny queen my face  look like an old woman’s ass when she try to shit. but my ass is a big hole. any thing and everything will get inside my hole. i have no hole in the front , only a penis.people shit on my face when they see how ugly i look. they think i am a freaky wild animal children run screaming if they see my ugly face, that’s why i hate Aiswarya Rai. everyone loves her. so i fake so many names an comment.i am an ugly bitch.

I am a old tranny queen my face  look like an old woman’s ass when she try to shit. but my ass is a big hole. any thing and everything will get inside my hole. i have no hole in the front , only a penis.people shit on my face when they see how ugly i look. they think i am a freaky wild animal children run screaming if they see my ugly face, that’s why i hate Aiswarya Rai. everyone loves her. so i fake so many names an comment.i am an ugly bitch.

I am a old tranny queen my face  look like an old woman’s ass when she try to shit. but my ass is a big hole. any thing and everything will get inside my hole. i have no hole in the front , only a penis.people shit on my face when they see how ugly i look. they think i am a freaky wild animal children run screaming if they see my ugly face, that’s why i hate Aiswarya Rai. everyone loves her. so i fake so many names an comment.i am an ugly bitch.

I am a old tranny queen my face  look like an old woman’s ass when she try to shit. but my ass is a big hole. any thing and everything will get inside my hole. i have no hole in the front , only a penis.people shit on my face when they see how ugly i look. they think i am a freaky wild animal children run screaming if they see my ugly face, that’s why i hate Aiswarya Rai. everyone loves her. so i fake so many names an comment.i am an ugly bitch.

i am a Bangladeshi hooker with an ugly decayed face. my family has been in flesh trade( fuckinng men ). my mother, granny, great granny, great grate granny etc.were all hookers all of them died of aids. i have caught up with the virus. but i still hook old men. i hate beautiful people like Ash. why everyone praise her? because of her beauty? i should be praised!!! i have hooked more old men.

i am a Bangladeshi hooker with an ugly decayed face. my family has been in flesh trade( fuckinng men ). my mother, granny, great granny, great grate granny etc.were all hookers all of them died of aids. i have caught up with the virus. but i still hook old men. i hate beautiful people like Ash. why everyone praise her? because of her beauty? i should be praised!!! i have hooked more old men.

Like
Reply

i am a Bangladeshi hooker with an ugly decayed face. my family has been in flesh trade( fuckinng men ). my mother, granny, great granny, great grate granny etc.were all hookers all of them died of aids. i have caught up with the virus. but i still hook old men. i hate beautiful people like Ash. why everyone praise her? because of her beauty? i should be praised!!! i have hooked more old men.

Like
Reply

i am a Bangladeshi hooker with an ugly decayed face. my family has been in flesh trade( fuckinng men ). my mother, granny, great granny, great grate granny etc.were all hookers all of them died of aids. i have caught up with the virus. but i still hook old men. i hate beautiful people like Ash. why everyone praise her? because of her beauty? i should be praised!!! i have hooked more old men.

Like
Reply

i am a Bangladeshi hooker with an ugly decayed face. my family has been in flesh trade( fuckinng men ). my mother, granny, great granny, great grate granny etc.were all hookers all of them died of aids. i have caught up with the virus. but i still hook old men. i hate beautiful people like Ash. why everyone praise her? because of her beauty? i should be praised!!! i have hooked more old men.

Like
Reply

i am a Bangladeshi hooker with an ugly decayed face. my family has been in flesh trade( fuckinng men ). my mother, granny, great granny, great grate granny etc.were all hookers all of them died of aids. i have caught up with the virus. but i still hook old men. i hate beautiful people like Ash. why everyone praise her? because of her beauty? i should be praised!!! i have hooked more old men.

Like
Reply

my maa is a street prostitute so am i

i am not concerned about who is better choice. I am concerned about WHO WILL FUCKK MY WRINKLED VAGINA!!!!!   It always bothers me. 

i am not concerned about who is better choice. I am concerned about WHO WILL FUCKK MY WRINKLED VAGINA!!!!!   It always bothers me.

i am not concerned about who is better choice. I am concerned about WHO WILL FUCKK MY WRINKLED VAGINA!!!!!   It always bothers me.

Thats why I said its my opinion. I have mer her with no make up and no hair done and I have to say that I do not think she looked nearly as pretty as she does on screen. And for that other stuff you dont know srk and amir in person you can not directly quote that. 

Aishwarya 

Sonia your wrong everyone is saying Aishwarya is more talented than Kareena too, that is a fact her acting has won her countless awards but Aishwarya’s beauty stands out  most that everyone is fascinated by it.

sick

sick mental

Who I would like to be with? one is rapidly approaching the big 40 and the other one still fresh like a petal. I guess you have the answer fat…i  ma

kareena is very cute! She has smth very charming, but Aish is the best! No one can be compared to her. She is the most beautiful, most talented  and  best dancer!

 don’t ever compare kareena to aishwarya! she is no match for her, aishwarya is a better actress and million times more beautiful.

Bangladeshi???…I’m not even Asian you bitch…get a job…your whole world revolves around me…but you’re too spineless to admit it!!!

hahahahaha yu deserve a medal th person who written ths zavah is another fat ass 300 pnd whore

fuck off bitch dnt try to front evrybdy knws yur tht bestyle bitch tht was here before!!!!!!!!! get yur ugly hairy loose pussy laid yu whore!!!!

fuck off bitch yur nt th real nisha!!!!

get laid old frustrated hood rat!!!!!

 it is yur mum tht is a bitch motherfucker!!!!!

hi doll hw is yu??? hw is yur studies??

get laid asshole!!!!!

koko

Bebo….

Ashwarya Rai ,,will be in a good position for Heroine..yes!!

ashwariya rai

aishwaria all the way

Heroine will be a flop because of Kareena. She does not have the style,maturity and look for the film. I agree like most others that Aishwariya would of been a better choice.
The film requires an actress with real life experience and not someone whose just lived their life in the hub of bollywood!

Aishwariya is the best and most beautiful woman, she is the better choice

ashwariya is the better choice for HEROINE and bebo can do this type of film . her film is done only by the hero and not herself execpt jab we met in which she only spoke bad language. ash pics in the film is really hot and sexy and pics of bebo is so cold